Webutuck's athletic director's contract terminated

WEBUTUCK — The Board of Education (BOE) voted to terminate Athletic Director Mike Riddle’s contract at the end of its workshop meeting on June 1.

The board was unable to discuss the specifics of the decision, but public comments during the meeting highlighted problems with coaching certifications and questions over the eligibility of athletes on the junior varsity baseball team that played on May 16.

Coaching certification

The Orange County Interscholastic Athletic Association (OCIAA, of which the Webutuck Central School District is a part) Web site links to the New York state coaching requirements law. The law requires that both classroom teachers and non-classroom teachers who decide to coach must have completed first aid and CPR certification as well as several coaching courses.

Riddle spoke to The Millerton News after the board’s decision about some of the issues in question. Audience members at Board of Education meetings have voiced concerns for some time, including the most recent one, as to whether all of Webutuck’s coaches have been properly certified. Riddle said that before he became athletic director, there were coaches who didn’t have the proper certification, but claimed that during his time as athletic director (the past two years), all coaches were certified or at least enrolled in the classes to become certified. Dennis Burkett, the assistant chairperson for the Mid-Hudson Athletic League, declined to comment for this article.

Baseball scrimmage

and tournament

The second issue of contention among audience members at the board meeting on June 1 involved two JV baseball matches, both scheduled on May 16. The first was a scrimmage against Poughkeepsie, where two modified athletes competed despite not having the proper health examinations required when moving a modified athlete up to varsity or JV competition. Rick Grossi, Webutuck’s high school nurse, and district Superintendent Richard Johns were either unavailable or declined to comment for this story.

On the same day, there was a second match scheduled for the JV team, which was to compete in the John Soracco Memorial Tournament at Pine Plains. The remaining JV players were set to play in this game, but the team was a player short and Riddle, who is not the regular JV baseball coach but was substituting for that game, decided to play a varsity athlete. He admitted that he had not read the tournament guidelines, which explicitly state that no varsity players, as defined by the tournament director, can play.

“If I had known, I would have called Pine Plains the night before and asked if that was OK,� he acknowledged, saying that he spoke with the tournament director before the championship game. The Pine Plains School District declined to corroborate Riddle’s statements or comment for this story.

Webutuck won the first game 3-1, with the varsity player pitching, and then went on to win the tournament. The player in question did not pitch in the championship game.

Several parents and citizens at the Webutuck BOE meeting on June 1 called the move cheating, and said it went against the school’s athletic policies. They questioned the motives behind the decision, saying that a win-at-all-costs mind-set was unethical and that Webutuck coaches should be teaching sportsmanship.

Riddle stressed that he did not and would not cheat, and was simply trying to create a better experience for the JV players by scheduling the players to compete according to their skill level.

“I will admit to my irresponsibility as far as moving kids up from modified, and then trying to backtrack myself to make sure they’re eligible,� he said. “It’s unfortunate that it went down this way, and I apologize for anybody who was hurt during this process.�

Board of Education President Dale Culver stated after the meeting that saying it was OK to break rules because other schools had done it before is “the kind of justification for something occurring that I can’t support.� Culver was unable to go into details about Riddle’s contract termination.

Riddle’s contributions

to the school

Riddle has been the athletic director at Webutuck for the last two years. During his time in that position he worked to create a mandatory 10th period study hall for athletes to get help on their school work. He also pointed out that he decreased the percentage of athletes ineligible for competition because of low grades, and that he “brought Webutuck sports to a higher level as far as competition.�

“I’m going to the miss the kids, and I’m going to miss the parents who supported me,� Riddle added. “I feel like I’m a pretty fair guy, and I sympathize with any kids whose feelings are hurt. “

Culver acknowledged that “there have been a lot of the changes in the athletic department that were positive this year, and we’re going to try to continue that.�

The board will discuss the athletic director position at the next board meeting, scheduled for June 10, after this paper’s publication deadline, but Culver pointed out that they might not find a replacement for Riddle by then.

Riddle said he has received another job opportunity but will continue attending Webutuck sporting events to see the spring season conclude this year.

“I’m going stick around to watch the baseball and track teams,� he said. “I’m still here as a supporter. The kids know it and that’s what counts.�

Latest News

John Fisher Polhemus

DOVER PLAINS — John Fisher Polhemus, 86, of Coventry, beloved husband of the late Gayle (Cronin) Polhemus, passed away Sunday, April 7, 2024, at home surrounded by his loving family. He was born July 30, 1937, in Sharon, the son of the late John A. and Gertrude (Fisher) Polhemus.

He grew up in Dover Plains, where he excelled in sports and academics. His mother, Gertrude, was his 3rd grade teacher and he couldn’t get away with anything. He loved to hike with his dad and brother Dick to the Stone Church and through the hills around Dover Plains. He graduated Dover High School and went to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, graduating with a degree in Aerospace Engineering.

Keep ReadingShow less
Nicholas Warner McClelland

CORNWALL — Nicholas Warner McClelland, 78, died peacefully in hospice care on Feb. 25, 2024, surrounded by his family. Nick was born in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania, on April 29, 1945, to the late Mary (Sharpless) McClelland and David C. McClelland. Nick was a graduate of the Cambridge School of Weston and Boston University.

After spending his formative years in Middletown Connecticut, Nick moved to Cambridge Massachusetts with his family. He spent many summers in Cornwall, later living in the greater Boston area and ultimately moving to Marblehead, Massachusetts, where he resided until his death.

Keep ReadingShow less
Fire investigator shares insights on safety-first approach

Fire investigator Laura Billon gives an overview of her work to the Falls Village Volunteer Fire Department.

Patrick L. Sullivan

FALLS VILLAGE — Laura Billon, a veteran fire investigator and educator from southern California, gave a detailed overview of fire investigation practices to an audience of firefighters and fire marshals at the Emergency Services Center in Falls Village on Saturday, April 20.

The event was part of the Falls Village Volunteer Fire Departments 100th anniversary celebration.

Keep ReadingShow less
Poem painting
Lans Christensen

Piper and Dexter Polley took part in “Paint a Poem” at Kent Memorial Library April 17 in honor of National Poetry Month. Assorted poems by famed authors such as Emily Dickinson were printed out and available for attendees to create their own painted poetry. A wide assortment of materials was provided and put to good use by enthusiastic painters.